Windows 7 vs Windows 8 vs Logic

Advertisement for Windows 8

Advertisement for Windows 8 (click to enlarge).

There is no truth in advertisements.  We’ve gone from “buyer beware” to “buyer be damned” by abandoning the rules of Logic for the sake of selling a product and making a profit.  Here’s a good example:

Advertisement for Windows 8 vs Windows 7

The advertising agency that put this together failed to understand one of the key components of marketing:  Never pit a company against itself.

Microsoft makes money by selling software.  The chart above clearly indicates that Windows 7 is inferior when compared to Windows 8.  So customers should purchase Windows 8 instead of Windows 7.  But both are made by the same company.

That would be like McDonald’s telling their customers to buy Big Macs instead of Quarter Pounders because Big Macs are vastly better than Quarter Pounders.


From a marketing standpoint, McDonald’s wants customers to believe that both are equally delicious and tasty.  It’s up to the consumer to decide which one they prefer while the company profits more by offering both.

Windows 7 is still supported until the year 2020.  It would be logical to compare expired, unsupported Windows XP to Windows 8, but not Windows 7.

Familiar Desktop:

Windows 95 through Windows 7 used a similar desktop environment.  The Metro user interface of Windows 8, however, was so radically different that it was considered unusable by many computer users.  Tech professional Brian Boyko created the best video analysis of  the Windows 8 graphical user interface:

Works with a mouse and keyboard:

True for Windows 7, not so much for 8.

As the video above demonstrates, Windows 8 was built for use on a touch screen enabled device.  Trying to mimic “swipe” gestures with a mouse is problematic at best.  The operating system can sometimes interpret the mouse movement as a finger gesture but often times not.  Which prompted many end users to initiate their own one-finger gesture towards Microsoft.

Works with Word, Excel, Outlook, and other familiar programs:

Which versions?  And what other “familiar programs” are they referencing?

Legacy support of older software programs is theoretically enabled in Windows 7 and 8, but not always functional in practice.

Games in particular that ran on Windows 98 though XP would no longer work correctly in newer versions of Windows.  Microsoft knew this and created Windows XP Mode for Windows 7 Professional, Enterprise and Ultimate versions only.  Little good this did the Home Premium version user, which was the default version of Windows on the vast majority of Windows computers sold worldwide.

Take note also that Microsoft Word, Excel and Outlook are purchased separately.  Microsoft no longer includes such productivity software with new computers pre-installed with Windows, like they used to do with Microsoft Works.

Built for touch PCs and tablets:

As far as we have been lead to believe, Windows 7 was never “built for” use on a touch screen device.  That much is true.

The mouse is an input device.  The keyboard is an input device.  The trackpad on a laptop is an input device.  A touch screen is also nothing more than an input device.  So if the proper drivers are installed, there is no reason why someone couldn’t use Windows 7 on a touch screen enabled device.  Right?

Windows Touch—available only in the Home Premium, Professional, and Ultimate editions of Windows 7—is fun to learn and easy to use. The Start menu and taskbar now sport larger, fingertip-friendly icons. All your favorite Windows 7 programs are also touch-ready. You can even finger-paint in Paint!

Faster startup times:

Faster than what?

This is a lie that has been foisted upon the consumer market since the release of Windows XP.

From a dead start (not suspend, not hibernate), from a completely off state, Windows 3.x would boot in the blink of an eye when loaded on the same hardware used by Windows 7 or 8.

The operating system has not gotten faster.  The hardware has gotten better.  This is easily proven by looking at the system requirements for past and present Windows versions.

For Windows 3.11:

The minimum client installation of Windows for Workgroups requires:

* 80286 microprocessor or better for version 3.1

* 80386sx microprocessor or better for version 3.11

* 2048 kilobytes (K) total memory for version 3.1

* 3 megabytes (MB) total memory for version 3.1 (2 MB with no network installed)

* 3 megabytes (MB) total memory for version 3.11 (4 MB is recommended)

* 6.2 MB of hard drive space (14.5 MB recommended)

For Windows 8:

If you want to run Windows 8 on your PC, here’s what it takes:

* Processor: 1 gigahertz (GHz) or faster with support for PAE, NX, and SSE2

 * RAM: 1 gigabyte (GB) (32-bit) or 2 GB (64-bit)

 * Hard disk space: 16 GB (32-bit) or 20 GB (64-bit)

 * Graphics card: Microsoft DirectX 9 graphics device with WDDM driver

Newer Windows operating systems could never run on the same hardware requirements as their earlier predecessors.   Modern software is increasingly dependent upon modern hardware for speed and functionality.

Apps from the Windows Apps Store / Mail, people and other built-in apps / Keep your settings and apps on all your PCs and devices:

Well, duh!

The implementation of “apps” only exists within Windows 8.  Users of Windows 7 would never miss these apps since they never had access to them.

People who use a specific operating system over an extended period of time become familiar with the functions and nuances of that software and with the available software packages for that system.  This true for Mac, Linux, iOS and Android users.

The idea that consumers would switch from Windows 7 to Windows 8 just to have access to the apps in the Windows store is a ludicrous argument.  The natural tendency for most people is to stick with what they know and what works for them.  This would explain why nearly 25% of all computer users are still running Windows XP.

Start Screen with live updates:

This is true of almost any operating system where the end user has enabled automatic login.  The start screen thus becomes the main desktop screen.  And if automatic updates are also enabled, the operating system would naturally update from the start screen.

So this is not an advantage of Windows 8 in particular.

Isn’t time for a change?

Windows 8’s uptake falls again, now slower than dud Vista

Microsoft wants you to forget Windows 8

Consumers vote with their pocketbooks.  The dismal sales of Windows 8 is a clear rejection of the operating system.

Even Microsoft can’t wait to put Windows 8 behind them.

The advertisement posted above is a total farce.  Don’t blame the company that sent it or the advertising agency that created it.  These people are just trying to do the best with what they have to work with.

Thank goodness that the buying public is smart enough to recognize the logical fallacies within advertisements like this one and make better-informed decisions about what not to buy.




One Response to “Windows 7 vs Windows 8 vs Logic”

  1. Halina S Says:

    It’s hard to come by well-informed people in this particular topic, however, you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: